How to Keep Your Whole Family on the Same Page About a Parent's Care
When care information lives in five places and three people's heads, things slip. Here's how to build one shared view your whole family can work...
10 min read
Alexis Villazon : Published
The holidays are one of the few times a family is in the same place with nowhere to be. That makes them a good time for a conversation most families mean to have and keep putting off: asking your parents what they want as they get older, and what they would want if their health changed.
It can feel like an uncomfortable thing to bring up. It helps to see it for what it is. Asking your parents about their wishes is a way of saying their choices matter to you, and that you want to get them right. This guide gives you the questions to ask, the follow-ups that get to the useful details, and what to do with the answers.
Pick a quiet moment during the visit, ask permission before you begin, and start with why you are asking: you want to follow their wishes, and you can only do that if you know them. Then work through five areas, in this order:
You do not need to cover everything in one sitting. If you only get through the first area, you have already had the conversation that matters most. The rest can happen over coffee the next morning, or on your next visit.
[DOWNLOAD THE PRINTABLE QUESTION LIST]
The big holiday meal is the wrong setting. There are too many people, too much going on, and nobody wants to feel put on the spot between the potatoes and the pie. Look for a calm stretch during the visit instead: a walk, a drive, the morning after, or the quiet hour when the dishes are done.
A simple opener gives your parent the choice to say yes. A few that work:
Use whichever one is true for you. The second works especially well, because it puts you in the same boat as your parent.
Ask your parent who they want there. Some people want every sibling present so they only have to say it once. Others would much prefer one child at a time. If a sibling can't be there, a recording or a shared summary (more on that below) means they hear the same thing you did. For more on dividing things up afterward, see How to Share Caregiving Duties With Your Siblings.
Your job in this conversation is to ask and listen. You are learning what your parent wants, which may be different from what you would choose for them. If an answer surprises you, a good response is "tell me more about that."
These conversations cover a lot of ground, and it is hard to listen well while taking notes. It is also common for two siblings to remember the same conversation differently a year later.
Neela's Scribe can record the conversation and write a summary for you. You start Scribe on your phone, set it on the table, and talk. Afterward, the summary can be shared with your care network, so the sibling who couldn't make it gets the same information as everyone in the room. Because the conversation is now part of your family's care information, Neela knows what was said, and you can ask her about it later.
Ask everyone before you record. Something like: "Would it be okay if I record this, so none of us has to take notes and we all remember it the same way?" If anyone would prefer not to be recorded, take notes by hand and add them to Neela afterward.
If you only have one conversation this season, make it this one. The National Institute on Aging encourages people to make these plans while they are healthy and able, and offers a free conversation guide that pairs well with the questions below.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: the person your parent names is their health care proxy (also called a health care agent or health care power of attorney). It only carries legal weight once it is in writing. If it isn't yet, that is your first follow-up task. Advance Directive vs. Living Will explains the documents involved.
This question does more work than it seems to. The answer tells you what your parent would want protected if their health changed.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: Write it down in their words. This is the answer you’ll lean on if you ever have to make a medical decision for your parent that no form covers. If a doctor offers a treatment that could add time but would mean leaving home, “a good day is being in my own house with the dog” tells you what your parent would choose. You’d be following their wishes instead of guessing at them.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: these wishes belong in a living will or advance directive, and a copy belongs with their doctor. The last follow-up matters more than people expect. Without a signed form, a doctor's office may not be able to share information with you. See HIPAA Authorization for Aging Parents for how to set that up.
Go through the list together. For each one, you are looking for three things: does it exist, when was it last updated, and where is the original.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: make a list of what exists and what is missing. If your parent is comfortable with it, take a photo or scan of each document so the family can find them later. Neela's Vault is a secure, HIPAA-compliant place to keep them, shared with the people your parent chooses. For the bigger picture, see the Family Estate Planning Guide.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: this is what a power of attorney puts in writing. How to Get Power of Attorney for an Aging Parent walks through the steps, and Can You Have Multiple Power of Attorneys? covers sharing the role between siblings. An elder law attorney can help with the specifics for your parent's state.
Money is often the hardest topic for parents to open up about. It helps to say plainly that you are not asking how much they have. You are asking how things work, so someone could keep them running.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: you are building a simple map: what gets paid, from where, and how. You do not need account access today. You need to know where to look. How to Manage an Aging Parent's Finances Without Taking Over covers how to help while your parent stays in charge.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: knowing your parent's priorities now makes later choices much clearer. For what the options look like, see How to Pay for Assisted Living and How to Set Up a Trust Fund for an Elderly Parent.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: most parents have a clear first choice and have never been asked about a second. Getting both now gives you a plan your parent helped write. Home Care vs. Assisted Living vs. Nursing Home explains the options.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: that last follow-up is the one to remember. If your parent tells you today how they want hard things raised, you have their permission, in their own words, when the time comes.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: agreeing on the signs ahead of time takes much of the sting out of this one later. See When Should an Aging Parent Stop Driving?
Many parents have thought about this far more than their children realize, and some are relieved to be asked. Go at their pace.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: if hospice and palliative care are unfamiliar terms in your family, Hospice vs. Palliative Care explains what each one offers.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: write it down and tell your siblings. A family that knows what was wanted can spend that time together instead of guessing.
Follow-ups:
What to do with the answer: this is often where the conversation turns warm. It is also a natural place to ask about family medical history, which helps your own doctors. Family Health History Questions to Ask Your Parents has that list.
Some parents aren't ready, and that is their call. A few ways to leave the door open:
The Conversation Project also offers free guides for families who are finding it hard to begin.
What you do in the week after is what turns a good talk into a plan.
Months from now, when a question comes up, you can ask Neela, and she can answer from what your family recorded and saved.
[DOWNLOAD THE PRINTABLE QUESTION LIST]
This guide is general information, not legal, financial, or medical advice. An elder law attorney and your parent's doctor can help with decisions for your family's situation.
Asking these questions is one of the most respectful things you can do for your parents. It tells them their wishes will be known and followed, by people who took the time to ask. This holiday season, find a quiet half hour and start with one question.
Complete the form to receive notifications when new blogs are posted. You will only receive an email once a month!
When care information lives in five places and three people's heads, things slip. Here's how to build one shared view your whole family can work...
Ensure a safe transition home with this hospital discharge checklist for an elderly parent, featuring essential tips to manage recovery and follow-up...
Discover how local siblings can share caregiving responsibilities with distant family through shared access to important information, reducing the...